Moneyball for Physical AI - by Animesh Garg

A Scaling Law Perspective for Marginal Utility per Dollar

In 2002, the Oakland Athletics won 103 games despite maintaining the third-lowest payroll in Major League Baseball. This advantage emerged because the market for player assets was mispriced: legacy scouts favored subjective aesthetics, stolen bases, and batting averages, whereas forward-looking management mathematically isolated on-base percentage, the statistic that actually correlated with runs. Finding the signal with the correct statistic in a field full of intuitive pundits: Moneyball! Data for Physical AI is misunderstood, and mis-priced. Data doesn’t exist for Physical AI. Data has…

related reading

• Animesh Garg on X: "Physical AI is making a classic Moneyball error by mis-pricing data. Optimizing for "cumulative operational hours" or relying on low-variance production telemetry is the robotics equivalent of chasing batting averages, wx.com
• Why AGI Will Not Happen - Tim Dettmerstimdettmers.com
• Generalist - GEN-0 / Embodied Foundation Models That Scale with Physical Interactiongeneralistai.com
• A Stargate for Data - by willdepue - Will DePuewilldepue.substack.com
• Dario Amodei — "We are near the end of the exponential"dwarkesh.com
• Bessemer Predicts: Robotics and physical AI - Bessemer Venture Partnersbvp.com
• Scaling is subtler than it seemsberen.io
• Android Dreamsandroid-dreams.ai
• Nikolaus West (@NikolausWest) on Xx.com
• Many Small Steps for Robots, One Giant Leap for Mankindnotboring.co
• AI progress is about to speed up | Epoch AIepoch.ai
• Ilya Sutskever — We're moving from the age of scaling to the age of researchdwarkesh.com