Original Position Fallacy - matthewmcateer.me
Had a discussion with a friend about this concept regarding its connection to a completely unrelated topic. Still, I felt like some of the main points were worth reiterating here in light of recent events. Picture that Kyle invited to a big party for 100 people at some influencer’s house. When he arrives, it’s revealed that there’s been a mistake with the DoorDash order: There’s enough of the burrito bowls for the first 50 guests, but everyone else will have to make do with a salad. Kyle looks around the room, and see that the place is still well under half-full, and say “that sounds fair” to the host. Of course, once Kyle goes into the second room, and sees it full of the 50 guests that arrived earlier, does he realize he’s in the group that won’t get the full meal. This is a simplified example of the Original Position Fallacy in action. A person supports some kind of policy, action, or revolution because they assume they’re either A) in the group that will benefit from it, or B) not
Original Position Fallacy The opposite of the golden rule, and why it's relevant now March 19, 2020 Had a discussion with a friend about this concept regarding its connection to a completely unrelated topic. Still, I felt like some of the main points were worth reiterating here in light of recent events. Picture that Kyle invited to a big party for 100 people at some influencer’s house. When he arrives, it’s revealed that there’s been a mistake with the DoorDash order: There’s enough of the burrito bowls for the first 50 guests, but everyone else will have to make do with a salad. Kyle looks a
related reading
- Galaxy brain resistancevitalik.eth.limo
- [REPOST] Epistemic Learned Helplessness | Slate Star Codexslatestarcodex.com
- Do not conquer what you cannot defend — LessWronglesswrong.com
- Before the game beginssparcjcs.substack.com
- Rule Thinkers In, Not Out — LessWronglesswrong.com
- The gossip traperikhoel.substack.com
- The Fallacy Fallacypersuasion.community
- Lies, Damn Lies, and Fabricated Options — LessWronglesswrong.com
- Bad Problems Don't Stop Being Bad Because Somebody's Wrong About Fault Analysis — LessWronglesswrong.com
- Annoyingly Principled People, and what befalls them — LessWronglesswrong.com
- How To Be Good | The New Yorkernewyorker.com
- Local Validity as a Key to Sanity and Civilization — LessWronglesswrong.com