HeartMath Considered Incoherent | Slate Star Codex
A group called the Institute of HeartMath has been remarkably persistent at making their way into my hospital. A couple of months ago I had to go to a lecture where they trained us all in their “scientifically” “validated” “heart” “coherence” “technique”. And yesterday I had to attend a class where one of my attendings (who is otherwise an amazing psychiatrist and teacher whom I have a huge amount of respect for) pushed the same technique and their biofeedback device. And it looks like I’m not the only one. It looks like the US Navy is also “getting the coherence advantage” and that there’s an entire site dedicated to HeartMath for veterans and the military urging them to “apply for scholarships”. There are HeartMath training programs for teachers and managers ($3500 for a four-day workshop), for police, firemen, and first responders ($3699 for a four day workshop) and for doctors and clinicians ($1495 for an “interactive webinar”). There are HeartMath programs aimed at classrooms, inc
[Note: all opinions expressed here are my own. Nothing to be taken as medical advice.] A group called the Institute of HeartMath has been remarkably persistent at making their way into my hospital. A couple of months ago I had to go to a lecture where they trained us all in their “scientifically” “validated” “heart” “coherence” “technique”. And yesterday I had to attend a class where one of my attendings (who is otherwise an amazing psychiatrist and teacher whom I have a huge amount of respect for) pushed the same technique and their biofeedback device. And it looks like I’m not the only…
related reading
- UsefulnessHarpers.pdfias.edu
- A Future for Neuroscience · opentheory.netopentheory.net
- Effect of breathwork on stress and mental health: A meta-analysis of randomised-controlled trialsnature.com
- Notice your limp heart until it becomes a rose-colored meteorsashachapin.substack.com
- The Art + Science of Breathwork: A Beginner's Guideconni.me
- How Breath-Control Can Change Your Life: A Systematic Review on Psycho-Physiological Correlates of Slow Breathing - PMCncbi.nlm.nih.gov
- Effect of rosary prayer and yoga mantras on autonomic cardiovascular rhythms: comparative study - PubMedpubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
- The Science of Woo—Asteriskasteriskmag.com
- [2606.29698] Clear Mind: Meditation and the Brain's Signal-to-Noise Ratioarxiv.org
- The egregore passes you bytheintrinsicperspective.com
- The entropic heart: Tracking the psychedelic state via heart rate dynamicsbiorxiv.org
- Schulich Heart Researchsunnybrook.ca